Umbrella Insurance
We’ll shop and help you save on your Florida Umbrella insurance.
Umbrella Insurance
Last updated:
What Is a Personal Umbrella Policy and Who Needs One in Florida?
A personal umbrella policy sits on top of your auto, home, rental property, boat, or motorcycle coverage. When a claim blows through the limit on one of those policies, the umbrella pays what comes next. Most carriers sell it in $1 million to $5 million layers.
Augustyniak Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Jacksonville. We do not work for one insurance company. We compare umbrella coverage from Auto-Owners, RLI, Progressive, Nationwide, Travelers, AAA, Geico, Liberty Mutual, USLI, and others to find the right fit for your household.
This page answers the questions Jacksonville homeowners actually ask about umbrella insurance:
- How much does an umbrella policy cost in Florida?
- How much coverage do I need?
- What underlying liability limits do I have to carry first?
- Is it cheaper to just raise my auto limits instead?
- Can I buy umbrella without switching my auto insurance?
- Does it include uninsured motorist coverage?
Want to skip ahead? Request your free umbrella insurance quote or call (904) 268-3106.
We write personal umbrella policies across Jacksonville, Mandarin, San Marco, Riverside, Ortega, Avondale, the Beaches, Southside, Nocatee, Ponte Vedra, St. Johns, St. Augustine, Fleming Island, Orange Park, Middleburg, Fernandina Beach, and throughout Florida.
How Much Does Personal Umbrella Insurance Cost in Florida?
Unlike comparison websites that model hypothetical quotes, the numbers above reflect real premiums on real Florida umbrella policies we manage today.
Here is how those premiums spread across our book:
| Annual Premium | % of Our Book | Who Falls Here |
|---|---|---|
| Under $400 | 18% | Single or retired households, one vehicle, clean record |
| $400 – $600 | 33% | Most common. Homeowner, 2 cars, no teen driver |
| $600 – $800 | 18% | Homeowner with pool, boat, or one teen driver |
| $800 – $1,500 | 22% | Multiple vehicles, teen driver, or rental property |
| $1,500+ | 9% | $2M+ limits, multiple rentals, boats, or higher net worth |
Source: Augustyniak Insurance Group active Florida umbrella book, April 2026. Concentrated in Duval, St. Johns, Clay, and Nassau counties.
Your premium depends on five things: how many cars are on the policy, whether any drivers are under 25, how many properties you own, whether you add uninsured motorist coverage on the umbrella, and your claims and driving history.
The cheapest way to save money on an umbrella is to bundle. Our experience is that households buying umbrella alongside their auto and home through one agency pay significantly less than those buying stand-alone policies.
A clean driving record, higher deductibles on underlying policies, and a paid-in-full discount also help.
How Does a Personal Umbrella Policy Actually Work?
Umbrella insurance is a second layer of protection. Your underlying policy (auto, home, boat, rental) pays first. When that limit runs out, the umbrella takes over up to its own limit. Here is what that looks like on a real claim.
What a Personal Umbrella Typically Covers
- Bodily injury liability.
Medical bills, lost wages, and pain-and-suffering awards when you are held responsible for injuring someone else in a car crash, at your home, or on your boat. - Property damage liability.
Damage you cause to someone else's vehicle, home, or property beyond your underlying policy's limit. - Legal defense costs.
Attorney fees and court costs when you are sued. Most policies cover defense in addition to the liability limit, though forms vary by carrier. - Personal injury claims.
Libel, slander, defamation, false arrest, invasion of privacy. These are often excluded on base policies. - Worldwide coverage, in most cases.
You are usually protected whether the incident happens in Florida, elsewhere in the U.S., or traveling abroad. - Landlord liability on personally titled rentals.
If you own a rental home in your name and a tenant or guest is injured, the umbrella typically extends over your landlord insurance policy.
What a Personal Umbrella Does Not Cover
- Your own injuries or your own property.
Umbrella is third-party liability insurance. It pays when you hurt someone else. It does not pay for your own car, your own home, or your own medical bills. The exception is excess uninsured motorist coverage, discussed below. - Business activities.
If you run a side business, operate a rental LLC, or drive for Uber or DoorDash, those exposures need commercial umbrella insurance, not personal. - Intentional or criminal acts.
Anything you did on purpose to cause harm is not covered. Neither is anything illegal. - Contractual liability.
Obligations you voluntarily take on in a contract are generally excluded. - Excluded vehicles, boats, or recreational items.
Anything not listed on an underlying policy, or anything the umbrella carrier specifically excludes.
Not Sure if Your Current Limits Are Enough?
Send us your auto, home, and boat declarations pages. We review the gaps and tell you if an umbrella makes sense for your household. Honest answer, no pressure.
No obligation. Most quotes returned same day or next business day.Start Your Umbrella Quote Right Here
Answer a few quick questions. We compare umbrella quotes from multiple Florida carriers and send your options back same day or next business day.
How Much Personal Umbrella Coverage Do You Actually Need?
The simplest rule: your total liability protection (auto + home + umbrella) should equal or exceed your net worth, plus what a jury could plausibly award against your future income.
A $1M umbrella works for most Jacksonville families. A $2M to $5M umbrella is more appropriate for higher earners, families with teen drivers, landlords, or boat owners.
| Coverage Amount | Who It Fits | Typical Premium |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000,000 | Homeowners with savings, one home, no teen driver. Starting point for most families. | $300 – $700 |
| $2,000,000 | Homeowner with a teen driver, a pool, a boat, or a rental property. | $600 – $1,100 |
| $3,000,000 | Higher-income household, multiple rentals, or anyone seeking more asset protection. | $900 – $1,600 |
| $5,000,000 | Significant assets, boat owners, or families with multiple teen drivers. | $1,400 – $2,500 |
| $10M–$25M | High-net-worth households. Typically written through specialty carriers like Chubb. | Quoted individually |
Premium ranges based on Florida market norms and our active book. Actual pricing depends on underlying limits, drivers, properties, and claims history.
Do You Need Uninsured Motorist Coverage on the Umbrella?
Florida has one of the highest uninsured driver rates in the country. The Insurance Research Council estimates roughly 20 percent of Florida drivers have no auto insurance at all.
That is where excess UM matters. In Florida, you can add up to $1 million of uninsured motorist coverage on a personal umbrella policy, on top of whatever UM you already carry on your auto. If a driver with no insurance causes a serious accident and your auto UM is exhausted, the umbrella UM fills the gap.
This is the one time an umbrella pays for your own injuries instead of someone else's.
What Liability Limits Do You Need Before You Can Buy Umbrella Insurance?
Every umbrella company requires you to carry certain minimum liability limits on your underlying policies before they will issue the umbrella. These are called underlying requirements.
The reason is simple: the umbrella only pays after the base policy has done its job. If your base limit is too low, the gap becomes the umbrella carrier's problem, and they will not take that risk.
Requirements vary by company. Here is what most Florida umbrella carriers ask for in 2026:
| Underlying Policy | Common Requirement | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Auto liability | $250,000/$500,000 or $500,000 combined | Some carriers now require $500,000. Applies to every vehicle. |
| Auto property damage | $100,000 | Florida's $10,000 state minimum is nowhere near enough. |
| Uninsured motorist (if adding UM on umbrella) | Matches your auto liability limit | Required to add excess UM on the umbrella. |
| Homeowners, condo, or renters liability | $300,000 | Most Florida home policies default to $100K or $300K. |
| Landlord or rental property liability | $300,000 | Rental must be titled in your personal name, not an LLC. |
| Boat, jet ski, or watercraft | $300,000 | Only required if umbrella extends over the boat. |
| Motorcycle, RV, or ATV | $250,000/$500,000 | Varies. Some carriers will not cover motorcycles at all. |
Requirements vary by insurance company. Some stand-alone umbrella carriers will accept lower underlying limits than preferred market carriers. We review the fit on every quote.
Is It Cheaper to Just Raise My Auto Liability Instead of Buying Umbrella?
Short answer: no. An umbrella does more and usually costs less.
Raising auto liability from 250/500 to 500/500 typically adds $200 to $500 per year for most Florida households. That only protects you in auto claims. A $1 million umbrella, which often costs $400 to $900 per year, does three things that raising auto limits cannot.
| What It Does | Raising Auto Limits | $1M Umbrella |
|---|---|---|
| Protects in auto accidents | Yes, up to new limit | Yes, up to $1M above auto |
| Protects in home liability claims | No | Yes, up to $1M above home |
| Protects in rental property claims | No | Yes, if titled personally |
| Protects in boat or watercraft claims | No | Yes, if umbrella extends over boat |
| Covers personal injury claims (libel, slander, false arrest) | No | Usually yes |
| Legal defense costs | Included, up to limit | Often in addition to limit |
| Cost per million of protection | Expensive. Each layer is incremental. | The first million is the most expensive. Each added million costs $100–$200/yr. |
The reason is structural. Auto carriers price every dollar of added auto liability at auto-claim frequency and severity. Umbrella carriers price the first $1M layer above the base policies, where claim frequency drops sharply because your underlying policy has already done its work. That is why umbrella costs less per million than raising the base.
One caveat: you usually have to meet the umbrella underlying requirements first. If your auto is currently at 100/300, you will likely need to move to 250/500 or 500 CSL before the umbrella is issued. That small auto increase plus the umbrella still costs less than raising auto to $1M in many cases, and you get the multi-policy coverage benefit.
Which Companies Offer Personal Umbrella Insurance in Florida?
As an independent agency, we compare umbrella quotes across multiple Florida-licensed carriers. The right fit depends on where your auto and home are written, what your underlying limits look like, and whether you need excess UM.
Auto-Owners Insurance
Writes a large share of the umbrellas in our book. Typically requires your auto to be with them, with flexibility on the home side given Florida's tight home insurance market. Strong financial ratings and a smooth claims process make this a common choice for Jacksonville homeowners bundling with Auto-Owners auto.
RLI
Stand-alone umbrella specialist. RLI does not require your auto to be with them. That makes RLI the go-to option if you are happy with your current auto carrier but need umbrella coverage now. Offers excess UM in Florida.
Progressive
Writes umbrella alongside Progressive auto. Competitive pricing, especially when teen drivers are on the policy. Usually requires the auto to be placed with Progressive at qualifying liability limits.
Nationwide
Typically requires Nationwide auto to write the umbrella. Home is often flexible given Florida's current homeowners market. A solid fit for households already insured through Nationwide auto, and for Nationwide Brokerage Solutions placements on non-Nationwide auto accounts.
Travelers
Typically requires Travelers auto to write the umbrella. Home is often flexible in Florida. A strong option for higher-value homes and multi-policy accounts. Offers excess UM in most cases.
AAA
AAA is the exception: it requires both home and auto with them as a bundled package. Umbrella is added as a layer on top of that bundle. If you already qualify for the AAA package, the umbrella is a simple add-on. See our AAA home and auto page for eligibility.
We also work with Chubb for high-net-worth umbrella needs, Liberty Mutual, Geico, and USLI for specific placements. If your current carrier does not offer umbrella, or offers it at unfavorable terms, we find a market that works.
Can You Buy Umbrella Insurance Without Switching Your Auto Insurance?
Yes, but only through certain carriers. This is one of the most common questions we hear.
Most major insurance companies, including Progressive, Nationwide, Auto-Owners, Travelers, and Geico, typically require your auto policy to be with them to write the umbrella. Home is often flexible given Florida's tight homeowners market, where those carriers may not always offer a home policy. AAA is the exception: AAA requires both home and auto as a bundled package before they write the umbrella.
If you are happy with your current auto carrier and do not want to move it, a stand-alone option usually makes more sense.
RLI is the main stand-alone option. RLI writes umbrella policies in Florida without requiring your auto to be with a specific carrier. You keep your auto wherever it is, meet the underlying limit requirements, and add an RLI umbrella on top. This is how many of our Jacksonville clients buy umbrella when they have a good auto rate they do not want to disturb.
Happy With Your Current Auto Insurance? We Can Still Help.
Stand-alone umbrella options are available in Florida. Send us your current declarations page and we will quote umbrella coverage without touching your auto.
Stand-alone and bundled options available.Who Should Seriously Consider a Personal Umbrella in Jacksonville?
Umbrella is not just for the wealthy. It is for anyone with something to lose. If you own a home, have savings, have future earning power, or expose yourself to daily liability like driving on I-95, you are a target for a lawsuit. Here is who our book of umbrella clients actually looks like.
- Homeowners with equity and savings.
Our median homeowners client has over $430,000 of dwelling coverage on their home. If a jury awards more than your auto or home liability limit, your home equity and retirement accounts are the next target. - Families with teen drivers.
Teen drivers are statistically more likely to be in a serious accident. A single incident on I-295 can generate medical bills that exceed a $500,000 auto limit. An umbrella is often the cheapest way to add real protection for a family with one or two teens. - Pool owners.
Backyard pools are one of the biggest home liability exposures in Northeast Florida. Guests, neighbors, and contractors all create potential claims. - Boat and personal watercraft owners.
Florida's waterways are busy. If the umbrella extends over your boat policy, a boating accident that maxes out the boat's liability limit triggers the umbrella next. - Landlords with personally titled rental property.
If your rental home is in your personal name (not an LLC), your umbrella typically extends over your landlord liability. See our Florida landlord insurance page for how landlord liability is structured. - Higher-income households and dual-earner families.
A jury can attach future wages to a judgment. The higher your earning power, the more you have to protect. - Anyone carrying 100/300 auto liability and wondering if that is enough.
It usually is not. The fix is to raise auto limits to 250/500 and add an umbrella.
If your situation is not listed here, call us. We have placed umbrella coverage for households that did not think they needed it and for high-net-worth families that needed $5M or more.
How Do You Get a Personal Umbrella Insurance Quote?
Three steps. No pressure. No commitment until you are ready.
Send Us Your Declarations Pages
Your current auto, home, boat, and landlord declarations pages. We confirm whether your underlying limits meet umbrella requirements.
We Compare Carriers
We shop umbrella coverage across multiple Florida-licensed carriers. Bundled, stand-alone, with or without excess UM. You see the options side by side.
You Choose Your Coverage
We present a clear recommendation with pricing. You pick the limit, carrier, and whether to add excess UM. We handle the application and activation.
Ready to Compare Umbrella Insurance?
One call. Multiple quotes. Real answers from a team that understands Florida liability.
Protecting Jacksonville families for 20+ years.Personal Umbrella Insurance Questions Jacksonville Families Ask
Is it cheaper to just raise my auto liability instead of buying umbrella?
No. Raising auto liability from 250/500 to 500/500 typically adds $200 to $500 per year, and it only protects you in auto claims. A $1 million umbrella often costs $400 to $900 per year and protects you across auto, home, rental property, and boat claims all at once. The umbrella also covers personal injury claims like libel, slander, and false arrest that auto policies exclude. Dollar for dollar, umbrella is the cheapest liability protection on the personal insurance menu.
How much does personal umbrella insurance cost in Florida?
Most Florida households pay between $425 and $904 per year for $1 million in coverage, with a median around $587. A single homeowner with one car and a clean record may pay under $300. A household with multiple vehicles, a teen driver, a boat, or a rental property may pay $1,200 to $2,500 or more. Pricing depends on underlying assets, drivers, claims history, and whether you add excess uninsured motorist coverage.
How much umbrella coverage do I actually need?
A good rule of thumb is to carry umbrella coverage equal to or greater than your net worth plus what a jury could award against your future income. Most Jacksonville families start at $1 million. Households with teen drivers, pools, boats, or rental properties often choose $2 million to $5 million. The cheapest layer of coverage is the first million. Each additional million typically adds only $100 to $200 per year, which is why higher limits are surprisingly affordable.
What liability limits do I need on my auto and home before buying umbrella?
Most Florida carriers require at least $250,000/$500,000 bodily injury liability on auto (some now require $500,000), $100,000 property damage on auto, and $300,000 of personal liability on your homeowners policy. Rental properties typically need $300,000 of landlord liability. Boats typically need $300,000. Some stand-alone umbrella carriers will accept lower limits. We review the fit on every quote.
Can I buy umbrella insurance without switching my auto insurance?
Yes, through certain carriers. RLI is the main stand-alone umbrella option in Florida, meaning RLI will write the umbrella without requiring you to move your auto. Most other companies, including Progressive, Nationwide, Auto-Owners, Travelers, and Geico, require your auto to be with them to write the umbrella (home is often flexible in Florida). AAA is the exception and requires both home and auto. As an independent agency, we compare both paths for every client: bundled with the auto moved, or stand-alone with your auto untouched.
Does a personal umbrella cover rental properties in Jacksonville?
Usually yes, if the rental property is titled in your personal name, not in an LLC or corporation. The umbrella extends over your landlord policy's liability limit. If the property is in an LLC, that is a business exposure and typically requires a commercial umbrella instead. We look at how every rental is titled before we place the coverage.
Does umbrella insurance include uninsured motorist coverage in Florida?
It can, but it is a separate endorsement you have to add. Florida allows you to buy up to $1 million of excess uninsured motorist coverage on a personal umbrella policy. Given that roughly one in five Florida drivers has no insurance, this is coverage we recommend for anyone buying an umbrella here. To add excess UM on the umbrella, you must carry matching UM limits on your auto policy.
Does an umbrella cover me if I have a teen driver on my auto policy?
Yes. Teen drivers are one of the most common reasons families buy umbrella coverage in the first place. The umbrella extends over the same auto policy that covers the teen. Some carriers surcharge more heavily for teen drivers on the umbrella, so pricing varies. We compare carriers specifically with the youthful driver surcharge in mind.
Is personal umbrella insurance required in Florida?
No. Florida does not require umbrella insurance by law. But Florida has one of the highest uninsured driver rates in the country, one of the most active litigation environments, and some of the lowest state minimum auto liability requirements. Given those conditions, an umbrella is one of the most cost-effective ways to protect a home, savings, and future income in this state.
What information do I need to get an umbrella insurance quote?
The fastest way to get a quote is to send us your current declarations pages for auto, home, and any boat or rental property policies. We also ask for the drivers in the household, any vehicles or recreational items, and your current umbrella policy if you already have one. Most quotes are returned same day or next business day.
Susan Augustyniak, CIC
Vice President, Augustyniak Insurance Group
Certified Insurance Counselor, licensed in Florida since 1999, with a background as a commercial underwriter at Nationwide before joining Augustyniak Insurance Group. Susan has personally placed thousands of personal umbrella policies for Florida families across Jacksonville, St. Johns, Clay, and Nassau counties. This page was reviewed and updated in April 2026.
Related Personal Coverage
- Auto Insurance Jacksonville FL — The foundation underneath most umbrella policies
- Homeowners Insurance Jacksonville FL — Home liability is the second layer the umbrella sits over
- Condo Insurance — Umbrella can extend over condo liability
- Renters Insurance — Qualifying underlying policy for renters
- Landlord Insurance Florida — Rental property liability under the umbrella
- Boat & Jet Ski Insurance — Watercraft liability that pairs with the umbrella
- Commercial Umbrella Insurance — For business liability exposures
- AAA Home & Auto Bundle — Includes optional umbrella
From the Blog
- What Is Uninsured Motorist Coverage in Florida? — Why Florida's UM rates make umbrella UM valuable
- Does Your Florida Auto Policy Have Bodily Injury? — The limit problem underneath every umbrella
- Florida PIP vs MedPay — How auto medical coverages stack
- How Much Does Car Insurance Cost in Jacksonville FL?
- How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Cost in Jacksonville, FL?
Important: The premium ranges, coverage descriptions, and carrier information on this page are for educational and illustrative purposes only. They are not a guarantee of coverage, insurability, or premium. Actual coverage terms, conditions, exclusions, and pricing are determined by the carrier and are subject to underwriting approval. This page does not constitute insurance or legal advice. For an actual quote and coverage recommendation specific to your household, contact our office at (904) 268-3106 or request a quote online.
Sources
- Augustyniak Insurance Group. Active Florida personal umbrella book, April 2026. Concentrated in Duval, St. Johns, Clay, and Nassau counties. Median annual premium $587. Middle 50% of policies fall between $425 and $904.
- Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I). "What Is an Umbrella Liability Policy?" Summary of underlying limits commonly required by umbrella carriers (typically $250,000 auto and $300,000 home). iii.org
- Insurance Research Council (IRC). "Uninsured and Underinsured Motorists: 2017–2023." Nationally, 15.4% of drivers were uninsured in 2023. Florida ranks among the highest states with approximately 20.4% uninsured drivers. insurance-research.org
- Ohio Insurance Agents. "Verdicts, Value & Volatility: Umbrella Market Under Pressure" (2025). The number of nuclear verdicts (jury awards exceeding $10 million) rose to 135 in 2024, a 52% increase over 2023. ohioinsuranceagents.com
- Gen Re. "Upward Pressure on Umbrella Loss Ratios" (2023). U.S. tort costs rose an average of 6% per year from 2016 to 2020, with personal liability costs growing at 4.4% annually. genre.com
- Florida Legislature. Florida Statutes Chapter 627, Part XI. Governs uninsured motorist coverage requirements and selection in Florida auto policies. leg.state.fl.us
- Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (Big I) / RLI Personal Umbrella Program. Stand-alone personal umbrella policy details, including underlying liability requirements and Florida excess UM availability. iiabsc.com
Get a 
